Synopsis – Two filmmakers investigate the disappearance of five children in their home town and the urban legend that grew from it.
Directors – Joshua Zeman | Barbara Brancaccio
Featuring – Bill Ellis, Ernie Anastos, Andre Rand
Released – 2009
Genre – Documentary
Cropsey,” directed by Joshua Zeman and Barbara Brancaccio, is a documentary that straddles the line between true crime and urban legend, resulting in a spine-tingling exploration of a real-life mystery. Set in Staten Island, New York, the film delves into the terrifying tale of Cropsey, a boogeyman-like figure used by parents to keep their children in line. However, as the documentary unfolds, it becomes evident that the origins of Cropsey are intertwined with a series of disturbing events, making for an unsettling and captivating viewing experience.
One of the strengths of “Cropsey” is its ability to blend the allure of urban legends with a deep dive into a true-crime investigation. The film begins by recounting the eerie stories of Cropsey, a sinister figure said to lurk in the woods and prey on children. This folklore is common in many communities, but what sets “Cropsey” apart is the connection it draws between these legends and the disappearance of several children in Staten Island during the 1980s.
The documentary takes a methodical approach to uncovering the truth, combining interviews with local residents, law enforcement officials, and journalists who covered the cases. This investigative aspect adds a layer of suspense and intrigue, as viewers are taken on a journey to uncover the facts behind the legends.
As the narrative unfolds, “Cropsey” introduces its audience to Andre Rand, a convicted kidnapper and presumed child murderer who becomes the central figure of the documentary. Rand’s eerie persona, combined with his proximity to the disappearances, makes him a chilling subject of scrutiny. The filmmakers explore Rand’s past, his criminal history, and his connection to the missing children, creating a sense of unease that lingers throughout the film.
The documentary also raises thought-provoking questions about the criminal justice system and the nature of urban legends. It prompts viewers to consider the impact of collective fear and how it can shape the course of an investigation and the fate of an individual. “Cropsey” serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of jumping to conclusions based on superstitions and legends.
Visually, the film is atmospheric and haunting, with dark and foreboding cinematography that mirrors the eerie subject matter. The use of archival footage and photographs from the 1980s adds authenticity to the storytelling, immersing the audience in the time and place of the events.
One drawback of “Cropsey” is that it leaves some questions unanswered. While it provides a compelling narrative and paints a vivid portrait of Andre Rand, there are moments when viewers may crave more concrete evidence and closure regarding the missing children’s cases. The ambiguity surrounding certain aspects of the story can be frustrating, leaving room for interpretation.
In conclusion, “Cropsey” is a captivating and unsettling documentary that skillfully navigates the intersection of urban legends and true crime. It offers a thought-provoking exploration of the impact of folklore on communities and the enduring fear of the unknown. By focusing on the enigmatic figure of Andre Rand and his connection to the legends of Cropsey, the film keeps viewers engaged and on edge throughout its runtime. While it may not provide all the answers, “Cropsey” is a chilling journey into the dark corners of human imagination and the mysteries that lurk beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary communities.
Roses Have Thoughts 
Leave a comment