Synopsis– Two close friends spend their last summer before going to college in pursuit of romance and independence, but their friendship is put to the test when they fall for the same man
Director– Naomi Foner
Cast– Dakota Fanning, Elizabeth Olsen, Boyd Holbrook, Ellen Barkin, Demi Moore, Richard Dreyfuss, Peter Sarsgaard, Clark Gregg, Kiernan Shipka
Genre– Drama, Romance, Coming-of-Age
Released– 2013
Very Good Girls is more engaging while you watch it than it is after it ends. The film has strong performances and captures the bittersweet feeling of a New York summer, showing real affection for the awkwardness of growing up. Still, Naomi Foner’s directorial debut tries to dig deeper than its familiar coming-of-age story can really support.
Dakota Fanning and Elizabeth Olsen play Lilly and Gerri, best friends spending their last summer before college. They make a pact to lose their virginity, which feels more important to them than it does to the audience. Their plans get complicated when they both fall for David (Boyd Holbrook), a mysterious young artist whose main appeal is that he’s good-looking, moody, and around.

The friendship between Lilly and Gerri is actually the most interesting part of the film. Foner, an Oscar-nominated screenwriter known for Running on Empty, understands that adolescence is more about small embarrassments and hidden resentments than big dramatic moments. It’s touching to see how these two can be inseparable one minute and quietly competitive the next.
Fanning gives Lilly a quiet vulnerability that fits the character, making her uncertainty feel real even when the script is predictable. Olsen is livelier than Gerri, bringing energy to the film. Their chemistry is strong enough that you wish the story focused more on their friendship instead of the weak love triangle.
The film’s biggest problem is David, who just isn’t interesting enough to justify the trouble he causes. Holbrook plays him with the right sensitivity, but the script never explains why these two smart young women are so drawn to him. Sometimes the film tries to make him seem deep by adding literary and artistic touches, but these mostly just make him look like someone’s idea of a sensitive guy.

The adults in the film are actually more interesting. Ellen Barkin and Clark Gregg play Lilly’s parents, while Demi Moore and Richard Dreyfuss play Gerri’s. Their performances hint at complicated stories beyond the teens’ immediate problems. Foner does a good job showing how adult struggles affect kids who are about to leave home. Sometimes the parents’ relationship feels more real than the main romance.
The film also does a nice job capturing its setting. Brooklyn streets, beaches, summer nights, and the nervous excitement of leaving home all give Very Good Girls a wistful mood. Jenny Lewis’s music adds to the feeling of a summer that’s half-remembered, when everything felt important but fleeting.
Unfortunately, Foner sometimes mistakes atmosphere for substance, spending too much time on feelings that the script hasn’t set up well. Some plot twists feel predictable, as if the film is just moving through expected emotional beats. In the end, the movie feels sincere but not always believable.

There is still a certain charm in its humility. Although Very Good Girls doesn’t fully capture the experience of young adulthood, it does capture the special kind of sadness that comes with being on the brink of it, and Fanning and Olsen make the friendship worth watching, even though the rest of the film fails to hold together.
This is a gentle, sometimes touching film about people drifting apart even as they wish things could stay the same. In the end, the girls themselves are more interesting than the movie about them.
Similar films
- Little Darlings (1980)
- The Sisterhood of the Travelling Pants (2005)
- The Last Days of Disco (1998)

Leave a Reply